Consultants in a BoxADPPaychexADP and Paychex guides
ADP vs Paychex

ADP vs Paychex: what each vendor's pages list, side by side

Short answer

On November 19, 2026, ADP's pages listed four small business plans for 1 to 49 employees and three for 50 to 1,000 or more, and Paychex listed four packages. Neither vendor showed a dollar price: both direct you to request pricing. So the real comparison is the plan ladder, the support and the integrations, then a quote from each for your headcount.

Last reviewed against the vendors' own pages. See sources.

Plans each vendor lists

Count of plans or packages named on ADP's payroll page and Paychex's payroll page, reviewed November 19, 2026. This is a count, not a price: neither vendor lists dollar prices.

Show as table
ItemPlans each vendor lists
ADP small business plans (1-49 employees)4
ADP midsized and enterprise plans (50-1,000+)3
Paychex packages4

What plans does each vendor list?

Per ADP's payroll page and Paychex's payroll services page, ADP splits its plans by company size and Paychex lists four named packages.

VendorPlans listedWhat the page says
ADPEssential Payroll, Enhanced Payroll, Complete Payroll & HR+, HR Pro Payroll & HR (1-49 employees)Enhanced is marked most popular; each plan adds to the one before
ADPSelect, Plus, Premium (50-1,000+ employees)Select is payroll and core HR; Plus adds benefits administration; Premium adds time tracking and attendance and is marked most popular
PaychexBasic, Foundations, Advanced, CompleteBasic is for essential payroll and HR needs; Complete is a full suite of HR, payroll, workforce and talent management tools

From the vendors' own pages, November 19, 2026. Paychex's page gives short descriptions of its packages, not itemized features.

How do support and automation compare?

Both vendors list live support and automated tax filing. The details differ in how they describe them.

VendorSupport listedAutomation listed
ADP24/7 live payroll support in every plan; live HR support from Complete Payroll & HR+ upAutomated federal, state and local tax calculation and filing; AI-enabled flagging of common payroll errors
PaychexPhone, chat and email; the FAQ describes self-service, on-demand representatives and dedicated payroll specialistsAutomated payroll tax calculation, filing and payment; WISE, its built-in AI, can prepare or run payroll for review; Pre-check lets employees review paychecks before payday

From the vendors' own pages, November 19, 2026. We have not tested either product.

How should you decide between them?

Match your headcount and must-haves to each plan ladder, then compare two written quotes on the same terms.

We can compare quotes with you and set up the connection to your books. See ADP pricing and Paychex pricing for what each vendor's page says about cost.

  1. Write down your employee count, states, pay frequency and whether you need HR support, time tracking or benefits administration.
  2. Find the lowest ADP plan and the lowest Paychex package that lists each must-have.
  3. Ask each vendor for a written quote for that plan: base fee, per-employee fee, setup, tax filing and any add-ons.
  4. Ask what happens at renewal and what it costs to leave, including getting your payroll history out.
  5. Check that your accounting tool connects. See the integrations guide.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, ADP or Paychex?

It depends on your size, states, support needs and the quotes you get. ADP's pages split plans at 49 employees, and Paychex lists four packages. Compare written quotes on the same terms.

Do ADP and Paychex list prices?

Not on the pages we reviewed on November 19, 2026. ADP says it personalizes pricing and uses Get Pricing buttons, and Paychex directs you to request a quote.

Do both offer mobile payroll?

Yes. ADP's page lists desktop and mobile access, and Paychex's page describes the Paychex Flex mobile app for running payroll and approving time off.

Can you help us choose and switch?

Yes. We compare quotes with you, plan the move and connect payroll to your accounting. Book a call to start.

Need help with payroll?

We help small and mid-size businesses compare quotes, switch payroll and connect it to accounting. See our ADP and Paychex guides and services, and the workflow automation service.

Sources

Last reviewed . Vendor plans and prices change often; every product claim and price on this page was checked against the vendor pages below on that date. Anything we could not verify was left out.

  1. ADP payroll (ADP)
  2. ADP small business payroll (ADP)
  3. Paychex payroll (Paychex)
  4. Paychex payroll services (Paychex)

Consultants in a Box is an independent consultancy. This page is not published or endorsed by ADP or Paychex. Neither vendor listed a price on the pages reviewed, and this page states no vendor prices and none of ours. ADP and Paychex are trademarks of their owners.

Choosing or switching payroll?

Start with the free business analysis, or book a call and we will talk through your payroll and a practical first step.

Book a free consultation

Tell us about your team and the software you need help with. We'll follow up to schedule a time to talk.

Open the form on its own page

Talk to a person

The fastest way is to pick a time. Prefer to write? Leave a message and we will email you back, usually the same business day.

Book a free call

By sending this you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.