Migrate from BigCommerce to Shopify Plus
Brands outgrow BigCommerce when they want Shopify's app ecosystem, Shop Pay and Shopify's checkout. The move is mostly data and apps, and we plan both.
Why brands leave BigCommerce
Shop Pay: Shopify reports up to 50% conversion lift when Shop Pay is available.
A larger app ecosystem for the tools you already use.
Shopify Markets for selling internationally.
Hydrogen if you run a headless front end today.
BigCommerce concepts on Shopify Plus
| On BigCommerce | On Shopify Plus |
|---|---|
| Stencil theme | Online Store 2.0 theme |
| BigCommerce apps | Shopify apps (most vendors list on both) |
| Headless (Catalyst, Next.js) | Hydrogen, or keep Next.js on the Storefront API |
| Multi-storefront | Shopify Markets and expansion stores |
| B2B Edition | Shopify B2B |
Your apps come with you
The app audit gives every tool a decision. The usual answers:
- Email & SMS: Keep: most have Shopify integrations. Retired tools (Bronto) move to Klaviyo or Shopify Email.
- Reviews & UGC: Keep: re-link existing reviews to Shopify products.
- Search & merchandising: Keep with their Shopify apps, or use Shopify Search & Discovery where it is enough.
- Payments & BNPL: Shopify Payments and Shop Pay; PayPal, Klarna, Afterpay and Affirm are supported; Adyen through Shopify's payments partners.
- Fraud: Keep with their Shopify apps, or use Shopify's built-in fraud analysis.
- Cross-border: Shopify Markets, Markets Pro, or keep Global-e on Shopify.
How we run it
- 1Discovery and app audit
We list every system and app the current store runs, what each one does, and whether it stays, gets a Shopify app, or is replaced by something Shopify does natively.
- 2Data mapping
Products, variants, customers, orders, gift cards, subscriptions and redirects are mapped to Shopify's model, including metafields and metaobjects for anything custom.
- 3Storefront build
A Shopify theme (Online Store 2.0) or a headless Hydrogen storefront, built to your design system and Core Web Vitals targets.
- 4Integrations
ERP, OMS, PIM, WMS and marketing systems connected through apps, Shopify Flow and Make, with error handling and alerts.
- 5Test and rehearse
Full data loads into a staging store, checkout and payment tests, redirect checks and a timed rehearsal of the cutover.
- 6Cutover and hypercare
DNS cutover in a low-traffic window, 301 redirects live, order flow watched in real time, and a hypercare period after launch.
Settle these before cutover
- Every URL that earns traffic has a 301 redirect, so search rankings carry over.
- Customer passwords cannot be moved between platforms: plan the account re-activation email.
- Open orders, returns and gift card balances need a clear owner on cutover day.
- Checkout customisations move to Checkout Extensibility and Shopify Functions, not script edits.
Frequently asked questions
We run a Next.js front end on BigCommerce. Can we keep it?
Yes. Shopify's Storefront API works with Next.js, or we can move it to Hydrogen hosted on Oxygen.
Will our reviews and loyalty data move?
Usually yes: most review and loyalty vendors run on both platforms and can re-link your data to Shopify.
Consultants in a Box is an independent consultancy that builds on Shopify; this page is ours, not published by Shopify. Shopify, Shopify Plus, Hydrogen, Oxygen and Shop Pay are trademarks of Shopify Inc.; BigCommerce and BigCommerce Enterprise and other names and logos belong to their owners. Last reviewed November 6, 2026.
Ready to plan your move from BigCommerce?
Book a call. We audit your apps and integrations for free and give you a written plan, timeline and quote.
