Consultants in a BoxWorkdayWorkday guides
Workday alternatives

Workday alternatives: how to compare before you decide

Short answer

Whether an alternative fits depends on what you need Workday to do: HR, payroll, finance or all three. Compare the same five things for every option, including Workday: total cost over several years, scope, deployment effort, integrations and how you get out.

Last reviewed against the vendors' own pages. See sources.

What should you compare?

Ask every vendor, including Workday, the same five questions and write down the answers.

Workday's own information is in the pricing guide and the integration guide. For ERP options from their own pages, see NetSuite and SAP. We have not published sourced comparisons of other HR tools, so we make no claims about them here.

CompareAsk
Total costWhat is the all-in cost over three to five years, including deployment and support?
ScopeDoes it cover HR, payroll and finance for the countries I operate in?
DeploymentHow long to go live, who does the work and what do I own?
IntegrationsHow does it connect to my CRM, chat, ticketing and files?
ExitHow do I get my data out, and what are the renewal terms?

Who usually looks for an alternative?

Most searches come from one of three situations, each pointing to a different kind of system.

  • A smaller business: wants payroll and HR without an enterprise deployment.
  • Finance first: wants an ERP, with HR a later step.
  • Cost pressure: a quote came back higher than the budget.

How do you run the decision?

Write requirements first, get comparable quotes and test with your own scenarios.

We can run this comparison with you. Book a call.

  1. List the processes and countries the system must cover.
  2. Request quotes for the same scope and headcount.
  3. Ask each vendor to walk through your payroll and approval scenarios.
  4. Check references of your size.
  5. Decide on total cost and the effort to run it.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Workday?

It depends on size, countries and whether you need HR, payroll, finance or all three. We compare options against your needs and tell you what fits.

Should a small business use Workday?

Workday describes Workday GO for organizations under 3,500 employees. Very small teams usually do better comparing simpler tools. See the small business guide.

How do I compare quotes fairly?

Use the same scope, headcount and term, and add deployment, integrations and internal time to every quote.

Can you help us decide?

Yes. Book a call and we will review your needs and recommend a practical next step.

Need help with Workday?

We help small and mid-size businesses compare, plan and connect Workday with their other tools. See our Workday guides and services, and the workflow automation service.

Sources

Last reviewed . Vendor plans and prices change often; every product claim and price on this page was checked against the vendor pages below on that date. Anything we could not verify was left out.

  1. Midsize business software and solutions, Workday GO (Workday)

Consultants in a Box is an independent consultancy. This page is not published or endorsed by Workday. Workday is a trademark of Workday, Inc. Figures shown are Workday's statements, not ours.

Comparing or connecting Workday?

Start with the free business analysis, or book a call and we will talk through your size, systems and a practical first step.

Book a free consultation

Tell us about your team and the software you need help with. We'll follow up to schedule a time to talk.

Open the form on its own page

Talk to a person

The fastest way is to pick a time. Prefer to write? Leave a message and we will email you back, usually the same business day.

Book a free call

By sending this you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.