Consultants in a BoxZapierMakeZapier guides
Zapier alternatives

Zapier alternatives: how to choose, and when not to switch

Short answer

Most teams look for a Zapier alternative because of the task-based bill, a need for more complex logic, or a need to control where data runs. Before you pick one, count your tasks on Zapier's pricing page rules, list the apps your Zaps depend on (Slack, Google Sheets and so on), and check each candidate's own pages for those apps and for how it bills.

Last reviewed against the vendors' own pages. See sources.

Why do teams look for an alternative?

The reasons are usually practical rather than about features, and they tend to show up as the account grows.

  • The monthly task total keeps pushing the tier up (see Zapier pricing).
  • Free is two-step only, and Zaps outgrow it (see the free plan).
  • Branching and error handling are getting harder to manage.
  • Several people need to build and maintain automations with shared ownership.

What should you check before choosing one?

Check these against each candidate's own pages, not a roundup.

  1. The apps each Zap uses: is there a ready connection, or will it need an HTTP call?
  2. How the tool bills: tasks, credits, runs or servers. Make, for example, bills credits (see Zapier vs Make).
  3. Where the tool runs and who can see the data.
  4. Who will own and monitor the automations after launch.
  5. How you will test the new version against live data before turning the old one off.

We only quote Zapier's and Make's own pages in this hub. We did not review other tools' pages and make no claim about them.

How is a move planned?

One workflow at a time, tested in parallel, with the old one kept until the new one is proven.

For larger estates see our Zapier to Make playbook, or book a call.

  1. Inventory every Zap, its owner, its apps and its monthly runs.
  2. Retire the ones nobody uses.
  3. Rebuild one low-risk workflow and run both side by side.
  4. Compare results, then move the next.
  5. Turn the old Zap off only after a full cycle, and keep a record of the settings.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Zapier alternative?

It depends on your apps, volume and who maintains it. We compare options against your actual Zaps and tell you if staying is better.

Is there a cheaper alternative to Zapier?

Possibly, but it depends on how many steps and runs you have. Count your tasks first, then price each tool on its own page.

Will I lose my automations if I switch?

Not if you run the new one alongside the old and keep the old Zap until the new one is proven.

Can you review our Zaps first?

Yes. Book a call and we will inventory your Zaps and recommend a practical next step.

Need help with Zapier or Make?

We help small and mid-size teams review, tidy, build and move their automations. See our Zapier guides and services, and the workflow automation service, and the Zapier to Make playbook.

Sources

Last reviewed . Vendor plans and prices change often; every product claim and price on this page was checked against the vendor pages below on that date. Anything we could not verify was left out.

  1. Zapier pricing (Zapier)
  2. Credits (Make Help Center)

Consultants in a Box is an independent consultancy. This page is not published or endorsed by Zapier or Make. Prices shown are Zapier's listed prices, not ours. Zapier is a trademark of Zapier, Inc. Make is a trademark of Celonis, s.r.o.

Reviewing or moving your Zaps?

Start with the free business analysis, or book a call and we will count your tasks and recommend a practical next step.

Book a free consultation

Tell us about your team and the software you need help with. We'll follow up to schedule a time to talk.

Open the form on its own page

Talk to a person

The fastest way is to pick a time. Prefer to write? Leave a message and we will email you back, usually the same business day.

Book a free call

By sending this you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.